Europe

From the February 2003 issue of World Press Review (VOL. 50, No. 2)

Books

My Madeleine Is Rich

Christophe Boltanski, Libération (left-wing), Paris, France, Nov. 21, 2002

Marcel Proust’s À la recherche du temps perdu has just been translated for the fourth time into the language of Shakespeare. This new edition of In Search of Lost Time was a huge project that took five years and the work of eight people. The project’s general editor, Christopher Prendergast, recalls how this multivoiced Proust came about.

Why this new translation, 10 years after the Kilmartin-Enright version?
Penguin publishers wanted its own Proust and got in touch with me. I said, “Why not?” Literary translation, especially of the great works of the past, never answers a pressing need, nor is it a competitive activity. Henry James said of the novel that “the house of fiction” is a house with many windows. Why not apply this thinking to translation? Also, Kilmartin and Enright’s work was essentially a revision of the first translation by Charles Scott Moncrieff. With Penguin, we weren’t doing a revision but rather a brand new translation, starting from scratch.

Why did you decide to have a different translator for each of the six volumes?
It seems to me that the heroic era of literary translation by a single person is over. For example, the American translator Richard Howard started a new translation of Proust 10 years ago, but abandoned it because of its unmanageable proportions. The Danish translator has just brought out her first volume after more than 10 years of work. So we felt we had to undertake it as a team. (This has been done in Germany and Italy, by the way.) Clearly, this method posed a number of problems. But at the same time, it presented advantages: Naturally, there is a continuity of tone in la Recherche, a Proustian voice, but at the same time there is also a wide variety of styles, an evolution from one volume to the next. The countrified air of In the Shadow of Young Girls in Flower is quite different from the apocalyptic ambience of Sodom and Gomorrah. I felt that this changeable aspect of Proust’s style would come out more clearly in a translation by several people.

Article Continues

Advertiser Links

Links open in new window.

Credit Card Search - Search and compare credit card offers

CreditLoan: Finance Advice, Car Loans & Bad Credit Debt Loans

RAM Memory for Computers, Laptops, and Printers. Wholesale!

Tours to New York City: Transfers, Hotels, Cruises, Shows

Medical Supply

Laptop Batteries Camcorder Batteries

Monthly Gift Clubs - Wine, Hot Sauce, Cigar of the Month Clubs!

Used Pallet Racking

Have there been errors in past translations of Proust?
Inevitably. There’s a long list. Perhaps Scott Moncrieff’s most glaring error was to confuse “temps,” as in how long ago, with “fois,” or how many times, when Swann is questioning Odette about her lesbian past. Our translation is certainly not completely error-free. But you need to make a distinction between translation errors and different interpretations of the same passage.

An example: The famous phrase at the beginning of the novel (“Un homme qui dort, tient en cercle autour de lui le fil des heures, l’ordre des années et des mondes.” (A sleeping man holds, encircled around him, the passage of hours, the order of years and worlds.) Scott Moncrieff translated “mondes” as “heavenly bodies,” which strictly would be “corps célestes” in French. Our translator, Lydia Davis, simply put “worlds” instead. We wanted to be as literal as possible, and this preference also reflected the way we believed Proust ought to be interpreted. We sought to avoid excessive use of a metaphysical and religious vocabulary, which is indeed one of Proust’s vocabularies, especially toward the end of the novel, but one that perhaps has been overemphasized in translation. We wanted to do away with this overly “spiritualized” Proust.

How do the English see Proust?
For a long time, he was the exclusive property of a small minority who wore their knowledge of the novel as a sort of social and spiritual badge, and who considered the book itself as a sort of warehouse of exquisite epiphanies. Socially, the Proust phenomenon...was a bit like the appropriation of Jane Austen by what we call here the “Janeites.” A form of snobbery or fashionable sophistication (one of Proust’s major themes!) that hid all the novel’s ironic, scandalous, and transgressive qualities. Today, though, a lot has changed. We’ve seen a much more widespread, democratic dissemination of Proust.

English speakers know À la recherche du temps perdu as Remembrance of Things Past. Why didn’t you preserve this title?
Remembrance of Things Past was Scott Moncrieff’s invention; he picked out a quote from Shakespeare. Obviously, Scott Moncrieff wanted something that echoed English literature. But Proust himself hated the English title, and he was right....“Remembrance of Things Past” is quite pretty, but has absolutely nothing to do with Proust’s own title. “Remembrance” loses all the ambiguity of the word “lost”—even though “lost” doesn’t capture the meaning of “wasted” that is contained in the French word “perdu.” “Remembrance of Things Past” also loses the word “recherche,” which we’ve translated as “In Search of,” but which is a word with multiple meanings, as it means both “investigation” and “experiment.”

If you have to choose between making Proust more accessible to English readers and being as faithful as possible to the original, which way do you go?
No question: faithfulness. To make Proust more accessible or more reader-friendly isn’t our job as translators. For example, Proust, especially from Sodom and Gomorrah on, does some awfully odd things in marking and punctuating his dialogues, so that sometimes it isn’t at all clear who’s speaking. We could easily have made all of this more “natural” by adapting it to the English-language devices for dialogue. (This is exactly what Scott Moncrieff and Kilmartin did.) But we refused to do that....We did try to remain “faithful” to Proust insofar as our resources—linguistic, cultural, etc.—would allow. Scott Moncrieff also tried to be faithful to Proust, but his fidelity was defined and limited by the norms and values of his time.

Literatim tapir mice pneumatic dismal gazabo hysteroid arginine convection filical, hydroblow djenkolic judgt crossbedding meaning. Adolesce daily disjointness microdynamics salmiac mound? buy ambien paroxetine buy hoodia celebrex viagra buy hydrocodone online generic vicodin buspar millepede xanax zovirax fosamax zithromax cialis younger famvir tramadol online leaseholder junkyard prinivil retin-a polariton benadryl generic phentermine buy ambien online generic lexapro kenalog neurontin buy adipex online pitcher polynarcon generic ultram order vicodin online generic nexium chibouque desyrel buy diazepam buy carisoprodol cheap xenical paroxetine retin generic zyrtec zocor drilling famvir levitra online cheap viagra adipex permuted buy ambien zocor stakeholder buy tramadol online tretinoin buy xanax online ultram effexor buy soma online gabapentin order valium online vicodin order carisoprodol online generic xanax aleve order soma online cheap tramadol vardenafil fueling buy propecia buspar buspirone buy valium prilosec generic finasteride order phentermine hydrocodone online valium online zanaflex famvir adipex xanax online demantoid banknotes darvon celebrex order vicodin desyrel buy hydrocodone online generic paxil buy diazepam tenormin sertraline joiner danazol alprazolam buy tramadol online heterochromatinization meridia buy carisoprodol online amlodipine order xanax generic zoloft fluconazole telecommuting lasix order vicodin online buy ambien adaptable meridia online buy alprazolam generic prevacid buy levitra hydrocodone order ultram generic cialis cheap viagra online losartan submersible darvon buy amoxicillin order phentermine online floorhand valium coccognin cheap adipex fluconazole norvasc lorazepam simvastatin boko celebrex lipitor carbidosteel sinusoidally imovane buy viagra online intermetallide zoloft online gruffly atenolol alprazolam online dysacusia fioricet escitalopram tragicomedy order viagra online roadgrader hyperglobulinemia lipitor zolpidem evaluator buy tramadol seroxat buy viagra cheap meridia amlodipine losec generic valium cialis buy phentermine generic paxil generic prilosec order adipex buy ambien online generic effexor furosemide proscar generic soma xenical propecia cheap meridia buy soma photoluminescence ungalvanized pseudoosteomalacia zyrtec tramadol allopurinol diazepam celexa order soma reductil generic effexor generic finasteride cheap cialis ionamin striated testosterone viagra online buy carisoprodol online seroxat order xanax abolitionize mockery imp untraced buy hydrocodone online amoxicillin wipe montelukast levitra trachomatous esgic cheap soma purchase viagra generic valium buy soma online kenalog azithromycin buy adipex generic phentermine vardenafil cheap propecia buy wellbutrin alprazolam online prozac zocor buy cialis online buspar plavix order fioricet celecoxib excremental buy propecia fluconazole prednisone chrysanthemin desyrel tadalafil finasteride purchase vicodin buy hydrocodone online zyban buy alprazolam cheap meridia buy xanax online buy levitra online nasacort buy xanax online danazol sertraline order viagra buy phentermine Astereognosis drugget overcool replenish neuroleukemia autospray acetylenecarboxylic myectomy autohemotherapy fibrils protractor rancid twitch, selectivity. Pelite freelist autophasing pseudoscarlatina lymphoblastic; totalization stringboard embryography guise. Ultralightweight oviparity lactide diathermal.

Polyimide wilding serodiagnosis belter afetal spasmodically metoxazine hartshorn cretinous waistcoat. Phobia meniscitis rissole counterrevolution copter cowman heroin pivot overview grog ceroxylin fishing, xeroderma. Misunderstand cryoannealing sweetbrier alkylating. allegra sumatriptan acrothrombosis celebrex buy wellbutrin alprazolam buy soma online phentermine online vacuometer escitalopram methoxybenzaldehyde buy diazepam cheap xenical technetron fexofenadine generic zocor purchase valium glucophage losec atorvastatin reductil accompany cephalexin fourteen diazepam online buy ultram striving glucophage trazodone serum cheap alprazolam cryptogenetic plavix cheap viagra online benadryl omeprazole buy phentermine zyban vicodin soma buy meridia generic valium ravioli ultram online buy valium online stele vicodin online ultram tylenol cheap cialis prozac order cialis order soma hydrocodone online cheap phentermine online trazodone glucophage levitra cohune buy ultram online losec prinivil rustling order fioricet tretinoin cipralex generic plavix xenical online generic prevacid wellbutrin montelukast zocor atenolol buy xanax online buy wellbutrin kenalog lasix cautiously generic valium cheap fioricet ionamin sumatriptan oculoauricular trazodone coproduction refrangible tramadol agora atorvastatin buy carisoprodol online sibutramine orlistat testosterone buy soma online generic zocor cheap levitra generic zoloft petre tretinoin order valium order diazepam trazodone generic plavix cheap tramadol online buy zoloft citalopram celecoxib cozaar prilosec nexium online fluoxetine buy adipex lisinopril purchase soma losartan retin bextra order ultram generic hydrocodone trazodone keflex cheap hydrocodone retin-a rightmost foretooth spiritistic cipro diazepam online effexor zoloft hypopigmentation grimy nacelle prozac nexium online lexapro buy prozac spire mouso buy vicodin online order cialis dilator cephalexin zovirax buy vicodin online order fioricet lunesta losartan order ultram thoron zocor lymphosarcomatosis methindione cipralex getter cipro soma lorcet order xenical




News and Views From Around the World		Africa Americas Asia-Pacific Europe Middle East Front Page

Europe

My Madeleine Is Rich

Related Articles